Home » REVIEW » Currently Reading:

Migrations – review

February 1, 2012 REVIEW No Comments

20120201 080540 Migrations – review

Lubaina Himid Between the Two My Heart is Balanced 1991 Tate © Lubaina Himid

poweredbyguardianBLACK Migrations – reviewThis article titled “Migrations – review” was written by Jonathan Jones, for theguardian.com on Tuesday 31st January 2012 16.09 UTC

 Migrations – review

Rarely have so many good artists been combined to so little effect as in Tate Britain’s lackadaisical survey of what should be a fascinating subject. Many of Britain’s greatest artists came to these chilly islands from other places. Others are the children of migrants, or identify themselves as part of a post-colonial diaspora. But what do they all have in common? It’s the question this exhibition forgot to ask itself.

It would be revelatory to see a hidden connection between Anthony van Dyck, the gifted baroque painter who became Charles I’s portraitist, and Keith Piper, whose 1987 work Go West Young Man powerfully digs into the history of slavery, seeing that past as something that shapes his own life as a young black Briton in the 1980s.

But Van Dyck’s ancestors were not sent across the Atlantic on slave ships. Nor are his portraits of Charles I and his queen, the only works by him here, enough to show us how his coming from Flanders shaped his view of Britain. It was no surprise, and no hardship, for a successful European artist to work at the English court.

For Van Dyck and the many Dutch 17th-century artists who get a work apiece here, moving to Britain meant something very different from the experiences of modern Jewish artists such as Mark Gertler, who was born in London to parents who had migrated from Poland. Gertler’s portraits of family and friends are potent documents of east London’s Jewish community a century ago.

Those differences could be overcome by intense narratives that focused on particular people and their experiences: the life and art of six migrant artists across six centuries, say. But instead this show goes for quantity, stacking up lists of artists, each of whom is represented by too few works, many of them having little connection with the theme. An exception, in terms of relevance and emotion, is Sir William Rothenstein’s 1906 painting Jews Mourning in a Synagogue, which seems to mourn an entire cultural tradition, at a time when pogroms shook eastern Europe and uprooted many people westward.

The exhibition takes a sudden turn into a survey of migratory themes in film and video art, because, we are told, the moving image is the natural art of a mobile world. If you say so. But it feels a bit easy to fill several rooms with projected images: looking from the dark screening galleries to the Stuart paintings, it is impossible to feel a thread of coherent argument. Tate Britain needed to think harder here, and it also needed to feel more. There’s something heartless about this catalogue of British art filed under M for Migration.

<a href="http://oas.theguardian.com/RealMedia/ads/click_nx.ads/guardianapis.com/artanddesign/oas.html/@Bottom" rel="nofollow"> <img src="http://oas.theguardian.com/RealMedia/ads/adstream_nx.ads/guardianapis.com/artanddesign/oas.html/@Bottom" alt="Ads by The Guardian" /> </a>

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

FAD NEWS

ART NEWS: Parasol unit’s 10th Anniversary Auction raises millions and breaks records at Sotheby’s

October 20, 2014

ART NEWS: Parasol unit’s 10th Anniversary Auction raises millions and breaks records at Sotheby’s

31 donated art works for Parasol unit’s 10th Anniversary realised a total of £2,092,250 at Sotheby’s this weekend.

ART OPPORTUNITY: Call for Entries Winter Pride UK Arts Awards 2014

October 20, 2014

ART OPPORTUNITY: Call for Entries Winter Pride UK Arts Awards 2014

Calling all Artists & Performers who want to make a difference! Open to all Artists & Performers regardless of their sexuality

The Top 5 Frieze Posts on FAD Last Week.

October 20, 2014

The Top 5 Frieze Posts on FAD Last Week.

The most read posts on FAD during Frieze Week

ARTNEWS: @GalleriesNow announce partnership with @FriezeLondon + @FriezeMasters

October 18, 2014

ARTNEWS: @GalleriesNow announce partnership with @FriezeLondon + @FriezeMasters

GalleriesNow.net have announced their new partnership with the Frieze and Frieze Masters VIP programme this year 2014. The services provided by GalleriesNow.net will include a Frieze-centric edition of the site (www.GalleriesNow.net/frieze), aimed at helping users negotiate their way around galleries and art-related events in the city as well as the two fairs, and daily versions [...]

This Saturday Do ART @Sanderson with Mr Brainwash + Dannielle Hodson #FriezeWeek

October 17, 2014

This Saturday Do ART  @Sanderson with Mr Brainwash + Dannielle Hodson #FriezeWeek

Sanderson is an official partner of Frieze London 2014 and they have brought together street pop art phenomenon Mr. Brainwash, and FAD favourite artist Dannielle Hodson for an exclusive exhibition and live interactive artwork.

ART NEWS: Get Free Art Now on #FreeArtFriday

October 17, 2014

ART NEWS: Get Free Art Now on #FreeArtFriday

Get free Art ….

FADNewYork Fashion News: For the Fall/Winter 2014 Season, Levi’s Vintage Clothing has continued its Orange Tab collection.

October 17, 2014

FADNewYork Fashion News: For the Fall/Winter 2014 Season, Levi’s Vintage Clothing has continued its Orange Tab collection.

Featuring core product like the 1960s 606 jeans, 1960s Chambray Shirts and 1970s Trucker Jackets, the collection is rounded out with special items such as the Sherpa Trucker Jacket and the 1970s Levi’s Sweatshirt emblazoned with the rare boxing rooster graphic from 1972.

FAD DAILY

FAD DAILY

Want brilliant, exciting and interesting art and culture news in your inbox every day? Course you do. Sign up to our newsletter below.

ADVERTISING