Home » Review » Currently Reading:

The British Museum’s Hajj takes us on a pilgrimage, not a propaganda journey

March 20, 2012 Review No Comments

20120320 162507 The British Museums Hajj takes us on a pilgrimage, not a propaganda journey

Powerful pilgrimage … Idris Khan’s Seven Times at the British Museum’s Hajj exhibition. Photograph: Idris Khan/Trustees of the British Museum

poweredbyguardianBLACK The British Museums Hajj takes us on a pilgrimage, not a propaganda journeyThis article titled “The British Museum’s Hajj takes us on a pilgrimage, not a propaganda journey” was written by Jonathan Jones, for theguardian.com on Monday 19th March 2012 13.33 UTC

In his Observer column yesterday, Nick Cohen really went for the British Museum. He argued that its exhibition Hajj glosses over a history fraught with violence, accepts a mythic official version of the early history of this renowned Muslim pilgrimage, and most seriously of all has allowed the regime of Saudi Arabia to sponsor and thereby influence the exhibition.

He says that: “In a piece for the American arts magazine Guernica, Joy Lo Dico embarrasses other critics by pointing out what was in front of their noses. Saudi Arabia provided exhibits …”

As a critic who gave the exhibition a five-star review, I have to say that I am not embarrassed in the least – just disappointed that such a red herring is being chewed on. I saw those exhibits and where they came from. Just like I see the BP sponsorship of art galleries. Neither is as significant as Cohen implies. Is he claiming that people will go away from this exhibition full of praise for Saudi Arabia, and if an Arab spring erupts there, will refuse to support it because they remember that groovy exhibition at the British Museum? Sponsors – even when they are also lenders – get very little in return for the largesse that enriches our museums. It just washes over us; it does not covertly influence us.

Hajj is not a mealy-mouthed liberal suck-up to Islamic countries or institutions. The reason it works so well as an exhibition is that it is not calculated or polite – it is passionately enthusiastic. The curator really sees something beautiful in Islam and wants to get that across.

Is Cohen saying the medieval pilgrimage routes that are documented in the show are fictional? The illustrations of north African pilgrims in illuminated manuscripts, prints of the Ottoman-era route, and astrolabes that were developed partly to calculate the direction of Mecca seem like social history to me. I did not imbibe any theological propaganda from these items – what I did get was a picture of a communal activity shared by generations of people across the centuries and today.

The British Museum may not have answered his questions to his satisfaction but the real answer is obvious enough. There are plenty of frightening representations of Islam around. And I am not speaking as a hypocritical liberal: the scariest “representations” of Islam have been created in the name of the religion itself, in fire and blood, by religiously motivated terrorists.

But are you saying there is nothing to admire in a religion that has lasted so long and has so many adherents? Hajj captures the strengths of Islam as a cultural force – it is about those strengths, and documents them well. The history it tells is not propagandist. In fact, he misreads it if he thinks it conceals evidence of political power. The Saudi involvement today is historically contextualised by displays that show how in every era, the dominant political power of the Islamic world has sought to appropriate and control the Hajj. When TE Lawrence blew up trains in support of the Arab revolt, he was disrupting a railway line the Ottoman empire built to show its commitment to Mecca.

There is another point to this exhibition too: a wider audience. The British Museum is full of Muslim families and school parties. This museum does not just exist for critics and columnists but for the actual people who, by being attracted through its doors, are encountering the many cultures and religions of the world. I think Hajj is a beautiful exhibition and I am not ashamed to say so again.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

FAD NEWS

Daniel’s Value and Ideas #44: Stealing Beauty

November 21, 2014

Daniel’s Value and Ideas #44: Stealing Beauty

The Winter Pride Art Awards celebrated its second year last Saturday with a ceremony at Tobacco Dock. It was a glittering event, with wild entertainment, fine food and fine art, not to mention plenty of cocktails. Behind the glamorous veneer of an awards ceremony to celebrate young, emerging artists, Winter Pride has a serious and urgent mission which is so often overlooked in the wider artworld

Artist Mark Farid + Virtual Reality headset + 28 days + living as ‘someone else’ #WTF ?

November 20, 2014

Artist Mark Farid + Virtual Reality headset + 28 days + living as ‘someone else’ #WTF ?

‘Seeing-i’ is looking at the construction of identities by culture and technology.

Artist’s ‘Driverless Car’ launches cutting-edge science hub

November 19, 2014

Artist’s ‘Driverless Car’ launches cutting-edge science hub

THE future of transport is on display in Newcastle upon Tyne at The Core, a newly opened building for future city firms at Science Central.

Art News: TBA21-Academy raises $187,500!

November 19, 2014

Art News: TBA21-Academy raises $187,500!

through the sale of Constant Dullaart’s encrypted treasure map and Aranda / Lasch’s Treasure Chest this evening, during Phillips’ Contemporary Evening Sale for Treasure of Lima: A Buried Exhibition: the latest art and conservation project conceived by TBA21-ACADEMY, the arts foundation chaired by philanthropist Francesca von Habsburg.

ART STUFF on a train # 82: ‘S p a c e d Out Crowded’

November 19, 2014

ART STUFF on a train # 82: ‘S p a c e d Out Crowded’

Most days art critic Paul Carey-Kent spends hours on the train, traveling between his home in Southampton and his day job in London. Could he, we asked, jot down whatever came into his head?

Global Launch of Ben Eine Objet d’art limited edition cubes in concrete, metal and wood.

November 18, 2014

Global Launch of Ben Eine Objet d’art  limited edition cubes in concrete, metal and wood.

Bringing the inimitable typographic style of Eine to life in 3D, limited edition cubes presented in concrete, metal and wood.

NEW FAD is almost here !

November 17, 2014

NEW FAD is almost here !

NEW FAD is almost here: a new design , a new extended editorial reach, easier to navigate and way easier to find out about our writers. COMING SOON WATCH THIS SPACE …

FAD DAILY

FAD DAILY

Want brilliant, exciting and interesting art and culture news in your inbox every day? Course you do. Sign up to our newsletter below.

ADVERTISING